Juli Mesa (Arrecife, 1990) holds a degree in Drawing from the UPV. Her first poetry collection, Soo (2023), won the inaugural Ana Santos Payán Award for Poetry Book Projects and was published by La Bella Varsovia. She has also published Lucio Blanca (Fundación Mapfre Canarias, 2023) and 1.& (LaDelfín, 2026). Her work has appeared in the anthologies Criaturas Laterales (Ediciones Poesía Círculo de Bellas Artes, 2025), Poesía Guarra (Disbauxa, 2025) and De alisios y volcanes: las nuevas voces atlánticas del siglo XXI (ICDC, Government of the Canary Islands, 2025).
Mariona Borrull (they/them) is a film critic for Fotogramas and a regular contributor to Gara, El Cultural, Kinótico and SER Catalunya’s Tot és Comèdia. They host 3Cat’s video podcast Replicants. Their journalism has focused on covering A-list festivals (Berlin, Cannes and Venice), alongside university teaching at the UOC and programming for L’Alternativa. They are a member of FIPRESCI and the board of the Feroz Awards, and took part in Berlinale Talents in 2022.
A film critic, programmer and teacher based in Belo Horizonte, Brazil. Throughout his career, he has combined a vocation for teaching with film analysis. His work extends beyond the classroom, establishing him as an important voice in understanding the aesthetic, political and narrative dimensions of contemporary cinema and strengthening the connection between films and their audiences.
As an essayist, his work has considerable international reach. He is currently a regular columnist for the Argentine publication Con Los Ojos Abiertos. His writing has also appeared in internationally renowned journals such as Cinética, Senses of Cinema, Kinoscope, Desistfilm, La Vida Útil, La Furia Umana and the historic Cahiers du Cinéma. His writing continues to enrich critical debate and the artistic appreciation of cinema around the world.
In 2018, after a decade marked by the severe economic crisis of 2008, its social consequences and growing public discontent with institutions discredited by numerous corruption scandals, the Muestra de Cine de Lanzarote decided to question a convention established at festivals around the world: jury deliberations behind closed doors. Since then, the winning film in the Official Section has been chosen in front of the audience. This was more than a change in procedure; it reflected a deeply held conviction: those who judge must be willing to explain the reasons for their judgement, defend it and reconsider it.
Yet simply opening the doors of a room was not enough. To make the experience truly meaningful, a meticulous, even painstaking procedure was devised and has been refined over the years. Every jury member must discuss each and every film in competition, explain their assessments, listen to those of the others and accept the possibility of changing their position. At a certain point, the audience may also contribute. It has been interesting to see how, on some occasions, observations from people who had attended all or almost all of the screenings have transformed the criteria initially defended by the jury. This is no small matter: listening means recognising that our own thinking can be enriched, and even corrected, by the thinking of others.
There is an element of spectacle in this experience, though not in a trivial sense. It is a spectacle of intelligence in action, where the pleasure lies in hearing how an idea takes shape, how an interpretation is defended and how a doubt prompts the reconsideration of a certainty. The aim is not to turn disagreement into a theatrical performance, but to make visible the work that judging requires. Awarding a prize means singling out one film among others that are equally valuable, and that responsibility deserves more than an unexplained verdict. What we seek is a form of aesthetic justice: imperfect, perhaps, and open to debate, but grounded in collective reflection and listening.
The Muestra de Cine takes particular pride in learning that this experience has begun to resonate beyond Lanzarote. The Cosquín International Independent Film Festival in Argentina has incorporated this form of deliberation into its programme. At a time when public debate too often seems reduced to shouting, personal attacks, imposition or concealment on social media, defending respect, nuance and reasoned argument has a value that reaches beyond cinema.
The Muestra de Cine de Lanzarote is a project organised by Asociación Tenique Cultural, a non-profit organisation whose main aims are to promote, screen and discuss independent cinema.
Awarding a prize is always an important decision. Every award explicitly recognises a proposal, a work or a contribution, whether cultural, scientific, sporting or of any other kind. At the same time, whether intended or not, awarding a prize usually establishes a certain hierarchy: in the view of a group of people — the jury — one particular contribution is better, more valuable or more interesting than the others submitted. An award also usually brings at least two additional elements: a financial sum, in some cases, and the prestige of receiving it, in every case.
For all these reasons, and because criticism or doubts about juries’ closed-door deliberations are heard all too often, five years ago the Muestra de Cine de Lanzarote decided to change the procedure for awarding the Official Section prize. In 2018, a specific methodology was developed for the jury to deliberate openly in the cinema, in front of the audience, allowing anyone who wishes to attend and listen to its reflections. Only people directly involved in producing the films in competition must remain apart from this deliberation.
Over these first five years, truly fascinating debates have taken place, with well-reasoned and carefully considered arguments. At each edition, the jury has faced different situations. Sometimes its criteria have led to a swift consensus; at other times, the decision has been far from easy. Nevertheless, every one of these open jury sessions has been an extraordinary experience, both for the jury members and for those listening to their views. Each public deliberation has been a moment of immense respect for what it means to think about cinema, to put forward arguments and defend ideas and, ultimately, for what awarding a prize entails.